Eddie Howe’s pause felt interminable. The lull only lasted seven seconds, but that is an age when answering a question.
Asked following the abject 2-1 home defeat to Bournemouth whether his Newcastle United players had the same “fire” inside of them that Howe had insisted he did, the head coach hesitated. Howe tried to downplay his hesitation by claiming he did not feel able to speak for others, but the delay was telling.
Howe’s silence was far more revealing than the words that eventually did come out of his mouth.
Like just about everything at Newcastle right now, the words being spoken simply do not tally with what the eyes are seeing and with what everyone is feeling. There is a big separation between the messaging and the apparent reality.
The future of the head coach is the primary case in point.
For months, the idea has been that Newcastle view Howe as part of the solution and that they would prefer to go into 2026-27 with the head coach still in situ. But for anyone in his position to retain the confidence of the club — even one as successful as Howe, who delivered Newcastle’s first major trophy in 56 years and has twice qualified for the Champions League — they need results. That is the currency upon which they ultimately survive.
Newcastle United have lost eight of their last 11 Premier League matches (W3). Since the start of this run on 25th January, they’ve lost more than any other PL side. pic.twitter.com/fTO8TjhGdx
— Opta Analyst (@OptaAnalyst) April 18, 2026
Yet, for the third game in succession, Newcastle succumbed to a listless 2-1 defeat. They did not throw away any more points from winning positions this time, granted — having ceded a Premier League-high 25 already — but it is now eight defeats in 11 top-flight matches, the second-most of any side in 2026.
That is relegation form, and if Howe did not have such excellent achievements to fall back upon, or progress in the cups this season to point towards, then a parting of ways may already have taken place.
Having a grand plan to retain the head coach and allow him to oversee a significant summer rebuild is all well and good, but when there are matches to be played before then, and Newcastle keep losing them, doubts about Howe’s longevity will only grow. Affirmation of the way forward is required.
The same is true of David Hopkinson’s hyper-ambitious ‘Vision 2030’, whereby Newcastle are aiming to be among the world’s elite by the end of the decade. Yet how does that correspond to a team languishing in 14th place in the Premier League, closer points-wise to the bottom three (11) than the top four (13), and who sold their best player last summer and will likely sell others during the upcoming window?
Even the assurances provided this week that Newcastle’s majority owners, Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund (PIF), are not considering selling and are fully committed felt hollow. Supporters have heard the same pledges for four years, yet the new training ground has still not been announced, and the stadium situation continues to be deferred.
Kieran Trippier’s post-match remarks offer another example of the detachment between words and reality at Newcastle.
Trippier felt obliged to speak to the media as a senior player (Photo: Stu Forster/Getty Images)
Nobly, the vice-captain offered to speak to the media after the game, despite only coming on as a half-time substitute.
“I’m a senior player. I feel like I have the responsibility to stand here and take the criticism,” Trippier said. “I’ll take it on my shoulders.”
But the problem was there was a disconnect between those comments and what happened out on the pitch, certainly before Trippier and Bruno Guimaraes were introduced during the second half.
No Newcastle player was taking responsibility, nobody was demanding the ball, and nobody was taking control. While Newcastle were not dreadful during the first half, they were toothless in attack — and their approach veered from the passive to the disorganised, with finger-pointing and some unfavourable body language.
Lewis Hall, Newcastle’s most-consistent performer this season, was hooked at half-time, so poor was his defending (though Tino Livramento could easily have been hauled off, long before succumbing to a thigh problem). But singling out players almost feels harsh, given Newcastle’s issues are chronic, with only three clean sheets in 26 Premier League games and one in their last 18 in all competitions.
What’s more, Newcastle’s offensive game plan was indiscernible once again.
Howe stressed that “rigidity is something we don’t coach at all — fluidity is”; yet Newcastle looked robotic and lacking in ingenuity before Guimaraes came on. The head coach insists he wants his team to attack and shoot more, but that directive is either not being given, it is not getting through to the players, or they are simply incapable of or unwilling to enact it.
The optics surrounding Anthony Gordon’s absence were also unfortunate. The winger was missing due to a hip problem but, following a week of intense speculation over his future, conspiracy theories abound. Increasingly, some supporters are suggesting insubordination is creeping in, and are wondering whether Howe retains the full support of the players.
His hold over the St James’ Park crowd is clearly waning. There were pro-Howe chants throughout, and the boos at full-time were not as angry and full-throated as they were following last month’s derby defeat, but an alarming five losses in six Premier League games on Tyneside has seen faith understandably erode.
Howe’s success has been built on imperious home form and, with that evaporating, the foundations of his tenure feel exposed. He requires buy-in from everyone at the club, including the supporters, but that relationship is coming under increasing strain.
“My belief in myself can’t waver — and it’s not,” Howe said, when asked if he doubts whether he is still the right person for the job. “That’s in every moment. In good moments, where I don’t believe the hype one way. It has to work the other way, where I have to retain a real belief in what I do. Despite what other people may say, that’s there.”
No matter what Howe says, so much about Newcastle looks and feels broken.
Leave a Reply